SwansPublic Castration Is A Good Idea

Label:

Not On Label (Swans Self-released) – BURN ONE

Format:

2 x Vinyl , LP, Album, Numbered

Country:

UK

Released:

Genre:

Rock

Style:

Post-Punk

Tracklist

A1 Money Is Flesh
A2 Fool
B1 A Screw
B2 Anything For You
C1 Coward
C2 A Hanging
D1 Stupid Child
D2 Another You

Companies, etc.

  • Pressed ByMPO
  • Recorded AtInstitute Of Contemporary Arts
  • Recorded AtThe Garage, Nottingham
  • Recorded AtUniversity Of London Union

Credits

  • Performer [Swans]Ted Parsons
  • Technician [Sound]Jack Balchin

Notes

First pressing. Numbered on rear sleeve. A second unnumbered pressing was released later, the unnumbered pressing can be found here: Public Castration Is A Good Idea.

Sides A/B/C recorded live at I.C.A. London 27/3/86.
D1 recorded live at The Garage Nottingham 13/2/86.
D2 recorded live at U.L.U. London 14/2/86.

A sleeve sticker may state Made in the United Kingdom. Some copies has small price sized "MADE IN ENGLAND K" sticker on one label.

Barcode and Other Identifiers

  • Matrix / Runout (Side A runout, etched): BURN 1 A¹ MPO
  • Matrix / Runout (Side B runout, etched): BURN 1 B¹ MPO
  • Matrix / Runout (Side C runout, etched): BURN 1 C¹ MPO
  • Matrix / Runout (Side D runout, etched): BURN 1 D¹ MPO

Other Versions (5 of 8)

View All
Title (Format) Label Cat# Country Year
New Submission
Public Castration Is A Good Idea (2×LP, Album, Test Pressing) Not On Label (Swans Self-released) BURN1 UK 1986
Recently Edited
Public Castration Is A Good Idea (CD, Album, Reissue) Thirsty Ear 57071.2 US 1999
New Submission
Public Castration Is A Good Idea (8×File, MP3, Album, 320 kbps ) Young God Records none US 2016
Recently Edited
Public Castration Is A Good Idea (2×LP, Album, Reissue, Remastered) Young God Records STUMM394, YG66 Europe 2022
New Submission
Public Castration Is A Good Idea (2×LP, Album, Reissue, Remastered) Young God Records YG66 US 2023

Recommendations

  • Cop
    1984 UK
    Vinyl —
    LP, Album
    Shop
  • Feel Good Now
    1988 UK
    Vinyl —
    LP, Album
    Shop
  • Young God
    1984 UK
    Vinyl —
    12", 45 RPM, EP
    Shop
  • Time Is Money (Bastard)
    1986 UK
    Vinyl —
    12", 33 ⅓ RPM, 45 RPM, Single
    Shop
  • The Seer
    2012 US
    Vinyl —
    LP, Album
    Shop
  • Greed
    1986 UK
    Vinyl —
    LP, Album
    Shop
  • Holy Money
    1986 UK
    Vinyl —
    LP, Mini-Album
    Shop
  • A Screw
    1986 UK
    Vinyl —
    12", 45 RPM, 33 ⅓ RPM, Partially Mixed
    Shop
  • New Mind
    1987 UK
    Vinyl —
    12", 45 RPM, Single
    Shop
  • My Father Will Guide Me Up A Rope To The Sky
    2010 US
    Vinyl —
    LP, Album
    Shop

Reviews

  • Dis777's avatar
    Dis777
    The rawness, authenticity and uncompromising nature of this live-record is probably best described by Swans. I know almost everything from them, but this 2LP is enough for me...this is SWANS!
    • RASCHX's avatar
      RASCHX
      I own this, and i will never never sell it. In the late 80s I told a friend of mine (he was listening to joy Division aso), to take a trip with this, and he was fascinated. I am still, after decades. I don‘t know about the reissue, but the original is insane.
      • g0727's avatar
        g0727
        I can’t compare it to the repress, but this sounds fantastic! One of my favorite records, and the material on the sleeve is cool. Play at MAX volume
        • feedkicker's avatar
          feedkicker
          Edited 2 years ago
          Pre-order available on the Young God Records (signed by Gira) and on sale on Mute (not signed by him) websites, the double LPs will come with a code.
          • nevnevnev's avatar
            nevnevnev
            It's coming, it's real.
            https://younggodrecords.com/products/public-castration-is-a-good-idea

            So glad I didn't drop $150 on an OG press.
            • interventiooon's avatar
              interventiooon
              Norman records just post this record for online sale for 25 pounds. Guess there’s a reissue available :)
              • TheAmazingRando's avatar
                TheAmazingRando
                This is *the* document of early Swans. I've had my copy for about 10 years and wouldn't trade it for anything.
                • wearesocialanimals's avatar
                  Gira posted on the Swans Instagram a USB stick with "Public Castration" stickered on it. Reissue imminent?
                  • scotters1969's avatar
                    scotters1969
                    My Copy:
                    Disc 1. Pressed onto 116 grams of Black Vinyl.
                    Disc 2. Pressed onto 132 grams of Black Vinyl.

                    Still plays very nicely indeed for vinyl that is coming up to 35 years old.
                    • wrechord's avatar
                      wrechord
                      Anyone know how many of these were pressed? Mine is stamped in the hundreds but there is a zero in the thousands indicating at least 1000 were pressed.

                      Release

                      See all versions
                      Data Correct

                      For sale on Discogs

                      Sell a copy

                      25 copies from €79.19

                      Statistics

                      • Have:856
                      • Want:1399
                      • Avg Rating:4.49 / 5
                      • Ratings:118
                      • Last Sold:
                      • Low:€40.00
                      • Median:€88.00
                      • High:€178.38

                      Videos (8)

                      Edit

                      Contributors